Colony Bank (CBAN) Q3 2025 Earnings Call Summary

1Key Financial Results and Metrics

Operating Net Income: Increased by $252,000 quarter-over-quarter, driven by higher net interest income and operating noninterest income.

Net Interest Income: Grew by $314,000, attributed to asset repricing and loan growth.

Net Interest Margin (NIM): Increased by 5 basis points to 3.22%. The company expects modest growth in NIM moving forward.

Operating Pre-Provision Net Revenue: Improved both quarter-over-quarter and year-over-year, indicating strong core earnings.

Loan Growth: Annualized loan growth rate was around 9% for the quarter, with a year-to-date growth rate of approximately 14%.

Total Deposits: Increased by $28.1 million during the quarter, with strategic use of brokered funding.

Tangible Book Value per Share: Increased to $14.20 from $12.76 year-over-year.

Charge-offs: Increased due to variability in the SBA portfolio, but overall charge-offs remained at acceptable levels.

2Strategic Updates and Business Highlights

Merger with TC Bancshares: Progressing as planned, with regulatory applications filed and shareholder meetings scheduled for November. Expected to close in Q4 2025.

Talent Acquisition: Welcomed Mitch Watkins to strengthen the Columbus market presence. Continued investment in talent to support growth strategy.

Noninterest Income: Increased by over $1 million, driven by higher fee income and strong performance in Colony Financial Advisors, Colony Insurance, and Merchant Services.

Credit Quality: Overall portfolio performance remained stable, with improvements in past due and classified loans.

3Forward Guidance and Outlook

Loan Growth: Expected to moderate in Q4, aligning with long-term targets of 8% to 12% annual growth.

NIM Outlook: Anticipated modest growth in NIM in the single-digit range, benefiting from recent Fed rate cuts.

Expense Management: Operating expenses expected to increase due to strategic hires, but overall efficiency remains a focus.

4Bad News, Challenges, or Points of Concern

SBA Charge-offs: Increased variability in charge-offs, particularly in the SBA portfolio, with expectations that this quarter represents the peak.

Government Shutdown: Monitoring potential impacts on borrowers, particularly in the SBSL division, though no material adverse effects are currently expected.

Wire Fraud Incident: Recognized a $1.25 million loss related to disputed insurance coverage from a previous wire fraud incident.

5Notable Q&A Insights

Impact of Government Shutdown: Management does not foresee significant impacts on the business or credit quality if the shutdown is resolved soon.

Loan Pricing and NIM: Average roll-on yield was 7.83%, with expectations for continued NIM growth despite a declining rate environment.

NDFI Loan Exposure: No meaningful exposure to non-depository financial institutions, maintaining a focus on relationship-based lending. Overall, Colony Bank reported a solid quarter with improved financial metrics and strategic initiatives, while also addressing challenges related to loan charge-offs and external economic factors. The upcoming merger is seen as a significant opportunity for growth.